Sunday, July 17, 2011

Grass-roots Meeting, the report card for your Boss

Grass-roots….. the dictionary defines grass-roots the following way:

“of , pertaining to, or involving the common people, especially as contrasted with or separable from an elite.”

Anyone see a problem with this statement? This is the culture of the largest retailer in the world. Involve the commoners, separate them from the elite and make them feel part of the decision making process all the while, having no intention of listening to ideas, comments or suggestions.

I’m glad I looked that up in the dictionary! Grass-roots defined by this retailer is getting in a room with your boss and telling him where he can improve….. WHAT? That’s right, as a group, the “common people” are shuttled into a conference room to discuss the boss’ performance with, hold on here, the boss. With the boss…… are you kidding? Unfortunately no, this process goes on once a year with your boss present. You just want to hide under the table. If they were really interested in what the commoners think, why don’t they have someone from HR get involved or another DMM, anyone but the person that can decide your fate.  

Let me back-up a bit here, the associates that answer to the DMM take a survey as to what the DMM is doing right and what they are not doing so well. This exercise is done with the utmost confidence (sure) in mind. Seems like a contradiction of terms, confidential survey. About a month later, a meeting is called and a “Grass-roots” is scheduled with all hands on deck.

I understand this practice has been going on for years, really. My first question is what executive in their right mind came up with this idea? Like most executives at this retailer, I bet they no longer work there, but the tradition continues. My second question is what employee in their right mind is going to say anything of substance or critique the person that has power over their livelihood? When the boss is leading the meeting, do you really think you will get the truth? Are you serious…..? This process is wrong on so many levels it boggles my mind.

So here you are, all the common people, sitting in this meeting with all of your common peers, and your elite boss is going through the responses to the questions that one or more of you have commented on. The meeting is not only presided over by the DMM but the responses are written on a board for later review. Then, the group is solicited on how to make the situation, process or morale better. Everyone knows that one of you in that room wrote the comment so someone better speak up. If you know what’s good for you, you will be a master of spin if you are called on for an idea. Generally, you can hear a pin drop in these meetings and participation is unsurprisingly low.

After the masses have spoken, or not, the responses are recorded and sent up the ladder where they are undoubtedly filed in a cabinet where they will collect dust until the next year. Actually, I believe that since this is part of the DMM’s bonus structure, he or she must show improvement year over year. If the same issue arises year after year, some type of correction is needed. Does this happen? More than likely not since most of the time the elite, (a group of persons exercising the major share of authority or influence within a larger group), are all protecting each other’s butts.

Does the term, fox guarding the henhouse come to mind here? Summary; the commoners rate the elite, the chosen one reads the comments, the same person calls a meeting to see what idiot made the comment, nobody speaks up afraid for their jobs, inane (lacking sense, significance, or ideas, silly) responses are listed for no apparent reason other than to end the insanity, all the commoners are dismissed and results are filed. The end.

Next week we will tackle sus·tain·a·bil·i·ty, noun.

Please comment if you have an opinion. I would love to hear from you! Unless you are one of the commoners that are in fear for their jobs!

Friday, July 8, 2011

Private Label Strategies

Not sure how to start off this commentary. I guess I should start with a controversial statement then give my points to back up my statement, rant a little then close with a summary. Ok, here it is….. One of the reasons Costco beats the crap out of Sam’s Club is because they have no clue how to build a private label brand. There you have it!
Costco has one private label brand, Kirkland Signature, named after the city of their first buying office, pre and post merger, in Kirkland Washington. Kirkland is a beautiful little lakeside community with a vibrant downtown and great places to eat…. but I digress as usual.
To get a Kirkland Signature item through the system and into the stores is quite a feat. If you are one of the lucky suppliers to have a KS item at Costco, congratulations because you have just endured the most rigorous, demanding, time consuming, frustrating process known to retail. Costco buyers like to say, “we don’t do anything fast, we do it right”, Amen! If you made it through the process of being scrutinized by upper management, a cost plus analysis, tons of paperwork, a colonoscopy and finally “Green Ink”, you have not only made your company lots of money, but as long as you don’t screw it up, you have an almost guaranteed income. Now get busy on the next item!
As I pointed out, Costco has….. ONE private label brand, yes I said brand because that’s exactly what it is. I know of no other brand that is so coveted and protected by any retailer in the US. Costco protects the KS brand because it is Costco and Costco is KS. It is also Jim Sinegal, his reputation is on the line each time a customer opens a bottle of olive oil, barbeques a hamburger, puts clothes in a suitcase or opens a sports drink. By the way, does anyone else have a problem identifying their luggage at baggage claim like I do? Black KS bags circle the turnstile like lemmings in every major airport I go to.
The procedure for getting a KS item into Costco is very simple;
1.      Quality. The item must meet or exceed the national brand
2.      The item must offer a 20% value to retail (I think it should be cost because retails can be manipulated).
3.      The non-private label item must exceed at least $15m in sales per year, (this number is a bit sketchy, have you seen the KS golf glove…. really?).
4.      Use one supplier, except where frozen chicken is concerned. That means your company must be able to supply the whole chain. Did I mention don’t screw it up?
5.      Advertising and marketing? Well, there is none, everything is netted down to the lowest cost possible, no demo’s, endcaps, fence, nothing. Net, net, net.
6.      Let me warn any supplier that is thinking of negotiating price with Costco. Don’t do it! The biggest mistake I have seen a manufacturer make is to not give the buyer the best cost up front the first time. Then, try to negotiate across the desk and play poker. Believe me; the manufacturer/supplier always loses!
7.      Be ready to drop your pants.
8.      Then there is the arduous waiting as all your hard work goes through the “management committee” until it finally gets to Mr. Sinegal’ desk. Yes, he does use green ink.
9.      If you are fortunate to make it to this point, you have to wait for the graphics department to complete the package artwork, have your packaging experts develop the label, case, pallet this whole process could take up to a year to complete.

Sinegal says, “We will always be known for name brands such as Michelin, Sony and Crest, but we will continue to augment our product offerings with our own Kirkland Signature Item” his goal is 20%.
Enough about Costco, lets pick on Sam’s Club. Sam’s has their Members Mark items named after one of the executives that have gone through that revolving door, Mark Hansen. I could be wrong but it’s too much of a coincidence and besides, Hansen has a big ego. Proforce which Ecolab was so gracious in giving to Sam’s Club, sure! And of course, Bakers and Chefs for the foodservice operators.
Now I hear that Sam’s is looking at three new brands: Artisan Fresh, Simply Right and Daily Chef, what cluster! At one point a couple of years ago, they were kicking around a high-end label for quality items. What kind of message does that send to their customer. Hey, here is Members Mark, don’t buy this because it’s crap! But here is our premium brand that is more expensive a worse value and not necessarily better quality. We just want to have a high end label so we can screw our customers.
So here is how you present a private label item to Sam’s Club. Take an item, wrap bacon around it, slap on a Members Mark label and call it a day, (those of you that are familiar with the freezer category will understand that remark).
In summary, which company do you think has the best P/L strategy? The guy that puts all his equity into one brand name and guards it like gold in Ft. Knox or the guy that’s going six or seven different directions not building any brand equity, consistency, quality or consumer following? I report, you decide.

Monday, June 27, 2011

The Death of the Buyer


Have you gone into a big box retailer lately and said to yourself “there isn’t anything new here”, “what happed to all the excitement and new items, I pay good money to shop here”, well you’re not alone. Oh sure, now that we are in the summer months, the transition to summer seasonal is in but it’s basically the same stuff we saw last year. There is no creativity on the Cart Rail, the transitions are poorly executed and the Fence is not much better. Again, it’s appropriate to the season but BORING! I have a theory;
The days of a buyer actually buying anything are going the way of the Edsel. Yes, I said it, the buyer is becoming obsolete and here is my theory;
Buyers are afraid to buy, afraid of failure and  afraid of being chastised by the boss.
Remember the days of Sol Price and that if one out of ten items was a success, he considered that a win? In addition, Buyers are turning into salesman. A very well know Club Store has a unique way of presenting and accepting new items, it’s called “the new items meeting”. At least once a week, a group of buyers will come together for a couple of hours and show their peers new items. These items are items that have been presented by a vendor to a buyer since the last meeting and the buyer feels that they have merit. How this works is that the buyers all turn into salesman and not very good ones. In reality, they don’t attempt to sell each other as much as they are trying to sell the boss.

Items are cooked, thawed, poured or prepared in some form or fashion for the weekly sales meeting. Each buyer prepares by filling out a form in hopes that the boss will grant their wish to purchase the item for sale in the retail establishment. The boss may ask for outrageous demands from the buyer that everyone in the meeting knows would not be efficient or in the best interest of the supplier. After the buyer presents to the group, the real decision maker will either give his/her blessing or condemn the item sending to the land of misfit merchandise. Thus, 1) destroying the self-esteem of the salesperson/buyer or 2) letting them off the hook because they really didn’t like the item to begin with but, they had to show something at the meeting that week or risk being asked if they were on vacation all week.

If 1) is the case, then what has been accomplished is disappointment by the salesperson/buyer, a missed teaching opportunity for the boss, an ever cautious buyer that is determined “not to go through that demeaning experience again” and a loss for the company and the consumers.

What really goes on behind these closed door meetings is a quid pro quo between the salespersons/buyers. The deal is that “if you say good things about my item then I’ll say good things about yours” and, along with a couple more conspirators, we can help each other. It turns into a game of us vs. them and degrades the morale and decision making process of the entire company.

As salespeople, suppliers, brokers and manufacturers, you are the experts on your items, (if you’re not, we have a whole new problem – another blog for another time). If you read some the high volume books on being an effective salesperson, one author suggests, “If you can’t get to the decision maker, You Suck! Well I have news for most of you who call on this particular retailer, You All Suck! Why? Because you can’t get to the real decision makers, it’s not the buyer; it’s their boss in the corner office.
Long gone are the days of quick decisions, fill out the paperwork right at the meeting table get a vendor number and item number in less than an hour, a PO in your hand by the next morning and goods shipping. Your product should be arriving in the Clubs in less than three weeks, in most cases sooner. What happened to getting to market first? What happened to making a quick decision and  a “deal is a deal?”
Now its exit strategy and markdown monies along with vendor holds before you even give the item a chance. Well, its a sad state of affairs that vendors have to depend on a buyer to give their item a good showing to be accepted in a club. Buyers should be buyers, salespeople should be salespeople and never the twain shall meet.
So here is the summary, you all suck because you can’t get in front of the decision maker. Suppliers professional lives are in the hands of buyers turned salespeople, some can do this effectively and some can’t. Russian Roulette?, you bet. So good luck all you sucky suppliers and vendors, your fate rests with a person that has no experience selling and is afraid to make a mistake.
One quick question, how do you know your item(s) are being presented in the new items meeting? You will never know what transpires behind those closed doors, No Vendors Allowed! 

Monday, June 20, 2011

Education vs. Experience

I was on one of the online sites recently and responded to this question; “When people are hiring, are they looking at Education or Experience first?”
To me, this is a very touchy subject and one that I have personally struggled with. I have over 30 years of practical experience in my chosen field but only have an AA degree from an accredited institution. However, I have over 30 years experience with two fortune 10 companies.
I have applied for many positions over the internet without much success. My experience has been that education is looked at as the weighing factor. In today's sterile world of “send a resume, strict guidelines”, good people get overlooked. Long gone are the days of personal interaction and face to face communications. Technology has taken the human element out of the hiring process, if you don’t fit into a particularly narrow bucket; your professional profile is set aside. Not considered are your decades of practical experience, interaction with customers and pure ability to get the job done. It’s really a shame that this is the new mold.
Last week, I printed up 10 resumes and cover letters for a entry level position that is below my knowledge and experience. I’m not a job snob, just looking for position that I know I am overqualified for, if given the opportunity, I would gladly take on the position and be thankful. I took the afternoon walking door to door in an industrial area, ignoring the numerous “No Soliciting” signs. I walked into places of business and was greeted kindly. Out of the 10 resumes delivered, 4 were leave behinds, 2 were friends that I ran into, one of which told me to go see the guy across the parking lot, they were thinking of hiring more help. 2 asked me to apply online to which I said I had and did not get a return reply and one just flat out told me they were not hiring.
I have often grappled with the idea of going back to school. I have kids in college that have or are working on a degree. A very expensive piece of paper that says, “I don’t have any experience in the real world but give me a six figure job”. Going back to school for me would be an online course, something I can fit into my already over-scheduled schedule. This is exactly the type of media that I am fighting against, I can’t win.
Being in the new world of entitlements, newly graduated young people have a different view of job hunting. Social media is all the rage and this is the direction we will keep going in as baby boomers are phased out and Gen X & Y’rs become a bigger part of the working force. Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, Yahoo, Google, MySpace and the 24 hour news cycle, “let’s call the whole thing off!” Unfortunately, you can’t put the crap back in the dog so down the superhighway we go.
For us that are caught in the middle, not quite ready to retire and a member of the over 50 crowd, this is a very scary time. Unemployment is at an all time high, the economy is in the tank, jobs are being shipped overseas; products are being sourced from out of the country and sold to you and me. This brings me to another question, what are we good at anymore? What does the United States make that is manufactured right here at a high rate and supports Americans with livable wages? Another time.
I guess I need to sum this whole rant up. Education vs. Experience, great question, I wish I had a good answer but I don’t. However, there is one thing I do know; If you don’t find a creative way around online job searches and the new social media, you are destine for mediocrity or early retirement.