Friday, July 8, 2011

Private Label Strategies

Not sure how to start off this commentary. I guess I should start with a controversial statement then give my points to back up my statement, rant a little then close with a summary. Ok, here it is….. One of the reasons Costco beats the crap out of Sam’s Club is because they have no clue how to build a private label brand. There you have it!
Costco has one private label brand, Kirkland Signature, named after the city of their first buying office, pre and post merger, in Kirkland Washington. Kirkland is a beautiful little lakeside community with a vibrant downtown and great places to eat…. but I digress as usual.
To get a Kirkland Signature item through the system and into the stores is quite a feat. If you are one of the lucky suppliers to have a KS item at Costco, congratulations because you have just endured the most rigorous, demanding, time consuming, frustrating process known to retail. Costco buyers like to say, “we don’t do anything fast, we do it right”, Amen! If you made it through the process of being scrutinized by upper management, a cost plus analysis, tons of paperwork, a colonoscopy and finally “Green Ink”, you have not only made your company lots of money, but as long as you don’t screw it up, you have an almost guaranteed income. Now get busy on the next item!
As I pointed out, Costco has….. ONE private label brand, yes I said brand because that’s exactly what it is. I know of no other brand that is so coveted and protected by any retailer in the US. Costco protects the KS brand because it is Costco and Costco is KS. It is also Jim Sinegal, his reputation is on the line each time a customer opens a bottle of olive oil, barbeques a hamburger, puts clothes in a suitcase or opens a sports drink. By the way, does anyone else have a problem identifying their luggage at baggage claim like I do? Black KS bags circle the turnstile like lemmings in every major airport I go to.
The procedure for getting a KS item into Costco is very simple;
1.      Quality. The item must meet or exceed the national brand
2.      The item must offer a 20% value to retail (I think it should be cost because retails can be manipulated).
3.      The non-private label item must exceed at least $15m in sales per year, (this number is a bit sketchy, have you seen the KS golf glove…. really?).
4.      Use one supplier, except where frozen chicken is concerned. That means your company must be able to supply the whole chain. Did I mention don’t screw it up?
5.      Advertising and marketing? Well, there is none, everything is netted down to the lowest cost possible, no demo’s, endcaps, fence, nothing. Net, net, net.
6.      Let me warn any supplier that is thinking of negotiating price with Costco. Don’t do it! The biggest mistake I have seen a manufacturer make is to not give the buyer the best cost up front the first time. Then, try to negotiate across the desk and play poker. Believe me; the manufacturer/supplier always loses!
7.      Be ready to drop your pants.
8.      Then there is the arduous waiting as all your hard work goes through the “management committee” until it finally gets to Mr. Sinegal’ desk. Yes, he does use green ink.
9.      If you are fortunate to make it to this point, you have to wait for the graphics department to complete the package artwork, have your packaging experts develop the label, case, pallet this whole process could take up to a year to complete.

Sinegal says, “We will always be known for name brands such as Michelin, Sony and Crest, but we will continue to augment our product offerings with our own Kirkland Signature Item” his goal is 20%.
Enough about Costco, lets pick on Sam’s Club. Sam’s has their Members Mark items named after one of the executives that have gone through that revolving door, Mark Hansen. I could be wrong but it’s too much of a coincidence and besides, Hansen has a big ego. Proforce which Ecolab was so gracious in giving to Sam’s Club, sure! And of course, Bakers and Chefs for the foodservice operators.
Now I hear that Sam’s is looking at three new brands: Artisan Fresh, Simply Right and Daily Chef, what cluster! At one point a couple of years ago, they were kicking around a high-end label for quality items. What kind of message does that send to their customer. Hey, here is Members Mark, don’t buy this because it’s crap! But here is our premium brand that is more expensive a worse value and not necessarily better quality. We just want to have a high end label so we can screw our customers.
So here is how you present a private label item to Sam’s Club. Take an item, wrap bacon around it, slap on a Members Mark label and call it a day, (those of you that are familiar with the freezer category will understand that remark).
In summary, which company do you think has the best P/L strategy? The guy that puts all his equity into one brand name and guards it like gold in Ft. Knox or the guy that’s going six or seven different directions not building any brand equity, consistency, quality or consumer following? I report, you decide.

No comments:

Post a Comment